The 48th Annual Grammys was actually a better show than I've seen in recent years. Although we had to wait two hours for things to finally get interesting, it wasn't as bad as some of the ceremonies have been. The broadcast was performance-heavy, which was a good idea; after so many acceptance speeches, the mind starts to wander, and the fingers start to tingle with an urge to change the channel. Some of the more hyped performances fell flat, while others were surprisingly good. It was a long night, but I managed to stay awake through the whole show.
Madonna/Gorillaz/De la Soul
"Don't believe the hype"... Madonna's performance was boring. The Gorillaz were more entertaining, and they sounded better. Madonna didn't actually start singing until halfway through the song, when she finally began to huff and puff along with the backing track. I kept wishing that the performance had been limited to De La Soul and the Gorillaz.
Alicia Keys/Stevie Wonder
They did an a capella version of "Higher Ground", which was actually nice. Alicia was overly deferrential in an annoying way, calling Stevie, "Mr. Wonder" (which sounded jarring every time she said it), but Stevie was good humored enough to tease her when she tried to play a few notes through his harmonica, "Don't you put no spit in my harmonica, girl!"
Coldplay
...Yawn...
John Legend
He performed "Ordinary People", and really sounded much better than usual. I guessed that he might have been taking voice lessons, because the horrible raspiness of his that makes him sound like he drinks a 5th of vodka every day was kept to a minimum.
U2 and Mary J. Blige
U2 performed "Vertigo" and then Mary J. came out to duet on "One", which is my favorite U2 song. I'd been really interested in hearing the combination, but I was sorely disappointed. Mary did her trademark growling and screaming, and totally ruined the song. Maybe if she'd sung it alone it wouldn't have been so bad, but with Bono singing wonderfully beside her, the screaming just did not work.
Mariah
I've finally come to the conclusion that Mariah needs to warm up before she starts to sound good-- and I mean during the performance, and not before-- She started with "We Belong Together", which sounded awful (her backup singers had to take over for her), but she finally came into her own for her next selection, a gospel number, where she brought the house down. And thankfully, she was completely covered up (even her cleavage was covered by her hair extensions). Maybe Mariah should always travel with a church group, to save us from seeing all of her naughty bits...
The Sly Stone Tribute
I never thought that I'd ever see so many people that I absolutely hate onstage together all at the same time. Joss Stone, John Legend, Fantasia, Will I. Am... thank goodness someone had the good sense not to have all of these people singing at the same time. Joss Stone, John Legend, and Van Hunt sang together (how did Van Hunt get invited?)... Adam Levine looked like he felt sorry for Ciara as he watched her make some squeaky noises in the microphone. I think she gave up trying to sing at one point, and just stood there looking at Adam and the others... she was obviously clueless to what was going on... some guy named Randy Lima had the challenge of not straining his vocal chords while trying to yell through all of Fantasia's squawking... Randy Jackson from American Idol, Robert Rudolph, and Patrice Rushen were in the band... Aerosmith joined in, too... all of this before someone pulled Sly out of his sarcophagus and let him come out for a few minutes to sing two bars and play a little keyboard (in his platinum blond mohawk)... Sly soon left the rest to continue making noise by themselves.
Jay-Z/Linkin Park/Paul McCartney
It sounds odd, but this was one of the best performances of the night. I was surprised how well "Encore" actually mixed with the Beatles' "Yesterday". And the two younger artists held their own with Paul; you'd have thought that the end would have been all about Paul, but it was a nice blend.
Kanye West/Jamie Foxx
This performance of "Golddigger" had to be seen to be believed. Kanye and Jamie did a whole marching band/School Daze meets Drumline type of spoof, and oddly enough, it worked. It was campy, but very entertaining, especially the step sequences from the "Golddiggers" sorority and the "Broke Phi Broke" fraternity.
Herbie Hancock and Christina Aguilera
Christina proved what I've been saying all along: she makes beautiful music with the right people. All she needs is a stylist, and the right producers, and she could be another Mariah.
The rest of the show was pretty ho-hum, but that was to be expected. I don't know anyone who could stay riveted to one show for 3+ hours. And with the addition of the preshows (anyone who watched the one on E! now knows for certain that Ryan Seacrest is an idiot), it would take a lot of dedication to sit through the whole thing (without the advantage of TiVo).
Here is a complete list of the nominees and the winners.