Or should we even bother to find anyone new? Harrison Ford was perfect for the role, in his heyday, and there was hope that River Phoenix, who nailed it as a young Indy, could have carried the torch, but sadly, he died. When Harrison said he was "getting too old", that was the end of Indiana Jones (although, oddly, he went on to play Jack Ryan, and several other assorted characters who did nothing but run, jump, shoot and kill). Now there is a new Indiana Jones film in production, and we know that if this film is successful, then the studio will surely want to continue the series. But now that Ford really is older-- who would be the perfect choice to replace him?
Glenn McDonald muses over this question in PopMatters:
Reports are trickling in that Ford, George Lucas, and Steven Spielberg have finally agreed on a script and a schedule, and may start shooting the next Indiana Jones film this year. This can't be construed as anything but good news, but it does highlight a crisis I think we've been long neglecting to address: Who is going to step into old man Ford's boots when he's gone? [...]
Anyway, I don't know how much more mileage we're going to get out of Harrison Ford. Man, what happened to this guy the last 15 years? Han Solo! Indiana Jones! Deckard! But then he started getting bad haircuts and wearing an earring and leaving his wife, and next thing you know he's flying rescue helicopters for a living and dating Calista Flockhart. And I'm not even going to make any skinny-chick jokes here. Nosiree, no cheap shots in this column. But did you know she went missing for several days last July when she turned sideways at a charity event?
Rumors persist that the fourth installment of the Indiana Jones franchise will be titled Indiana Jones and the Colostomy Bag of -- no, I can't do it. I just can't make fun of Indy. Harrison Ford is really all we have left of a movie hero, and we have to hold onto him like grim death. Who else is going to power a franchise like Indiana Jones? Brendan Fraser? Please -- the guy's a career understudy. The Mummy movies play like a bad Mad Magazine genre spoof. That leaves, who, The Rock? Ice Cube? Vin Diesel? All these guys can do is wear tight t-shirts and scowl, or raise an eyebrow, or whatever they do. Forget it. Christian Bale? Batman Begins was a nice movie, but he still looks like an underwear model.
Obviously, it would have to be an actor over 30, since Indiana was an Archeology professor. But the list of choices is small, because, really, how do you choose a replacement for someone who worked so well? Why not just end it with Harrison?
Of course, Hollywood probably wouldn't stand for that, because there is money to be made, and tickets and merchandise to be sold...
I hesitate to pile on with the other Tom Cruise haters out there, since it seems so trendy these days, but if ever there were a movie star that I've despised from day one, it's Brad Pitt. I mean Tom Cruise. Whichever, I don't care -- I can barely tell them apart. Brad Pitt I hate because his hair always looks so good. It became impossible to ignore around the time of Legends of the Fall, a film in which Pitt played a rugged outdoorsy type with the immaculately styled hair of an elite West Hollywood gigolo. I tried watching that film for the storyline, but simply I could not take my eyes off that celestial mane! And don't even get me started on Troy. Did you know that the end credits of that film, there's a line that reads: "Starring Brad Pitt's Hair as . . . Itself!"? True...
And Cruise is such an extreme Hollywood construct, I have a hard time even wrapping my head around his existence. His contempt for us "little people" just pours off him in waves -- if you look closely, you can actually see the air around him warp and waver from the incendiary derision he radiates to all non-Thetans. It's easier to think of him as a kind of mass media celebrity android. That's why I actually like his crazy-ass Scientology bullshit. When you get to that level of fame and fortune, the only real way to get your kicks is to aim for immortality and omniscience. Scientology sells this fever dream to our most earnestly self-deluded celebrities, and it's a nicely efficient system, I think. They deserve one another.
Who else, if not two of the biggest stars in Hollywood? There are tons of big name actors who could do it, but could they really carry it off convincingly? This has the potential of mirroring the James Bond situation. Dozens of actors will covet the role, but only one will be lucky enough to be deemed rugged, charismatic, and talented enough to appeal to audiences. Personally, I'd rather just end it while it's still good.
"Popshots: The Last Action Hero" (PopMatters)